It's a well known fact, or should be by now with the large amount of books to movies we've seen over the last several years, that a movie adaption of a book is going to be lacking and modified from the original version. Catherine Hardwicke stated that their goal for Twilight was not to duplicate the scenes from the book but to get the overall "feel of Twilight" correct and, boy, did they ever! So much so, that a few scenes they took the liberties of adding to or changing from the book seemed like they came straight from the visions of vampires dancing in my head while reading Twilight for the first time.
For example, in the book when Bella was researching vampires on the Internet, I pictured in my mind scenes from old, black and white vampire movies. A glamorous Hollywood starlet draped in a diaphanous silk gown, neck exposed and a very hungry vampire at her throat with slick black hair complete with a widow's peak and dark red cape. Not that Stephenie mentioned anything even remotely close to this in the book, it's just a vignette even the smallest vampire fan reverts back to when you think of the classic vampire. So when we see Bella doing this in the movie it seems only natural that she has this sort of dream about Edward.
Some other very similar examples was the flashback scenes between the Quileutes and the Cullens during Jacob's telling of the "Cold Ones" legend. Again, it was something one has to imagine while he's telling the story in the book with the vintage clothing and what the Quileutes would have looked like and worn at that time period. I can't wait to see the Legend of the Third Wife played out on screen in Eclipse!
The revelation scene when Bella tells Edward she knows what he is worked perfectly as an intro to the content from the meadow scene. In the books they only run and hunt through the forest but when I saw pictures of the rain forests in and around Forks I couldn't help but imagine Edward and his family climbing up the the mossy branches and lurking in and around the ferns. I'm so glad they changed the location from the car to the forest for this scene. Not that the scene in the car wasn't intense and wonderful to read in the book but I like the visual in the forest better. I loved how he climbed up the tree and leaped onto the rocks as he demonstrated his power and explained his family to her. We just got to enjoy all of their surroundings more this way... I loved how Edward took her up into the trees and how Alice walks along a branch and then jumps down into the house. All this contributed to their animal- like movements and senses, their relationship to the natural world around them.
Another little thing they added that I loved was Charlie cleaning his guns before meeting Edward. In the book you get a sense that he is very protective of Bella but to mix that with his first meeting of Edward was just so classic. My hubby always says he wants to be cleaning his guns when Kaiya brings a boyfriend over the first time.
Other additions not in the book:
The apple scene that gave a nod to the book cover...loved it!
The kiss in the bedroom instead of the forest...enough said, really.
Victoria watching them at the end. In New Moon and Eclipse you get a sense that she is always watching them so this set the next two movies up nicely. Plus, Rachelle is just so darn cool and the window she is looking out is the window to the bedroom we stayed in at the View Point Inn. So cool!
Also, to showcase Alice's dance-like physicality they added in the twirl with Jackson during the lunch scene and the way she pitches the ball with her little pointed foot. So cute!
My favorite things about this movie:
All of the above, plus
The humans! Awesome! Michael Welch was a perfect Mike Newton and Justin Chon's Erik was hilarious. They were perfectly annoying as it should be.
Plus, in reality Peter is such a kind man so this only adds to his character.
I thought Robert did a fabulous job bringing Edward to life. Some thought his reactions were a bit too over-the-top but I didn't. Bringing those deep emotions of Edward's to the surface is a difficult task. What is too much? What is too little? How do you convey the impact of Bella's smell for the first time to an audience who has never read the book and how do you get it perfect for those who have? I think he was subtle and timid when he needed to be and strong when it was called for. It's always going to be difficult for fans of the book to picture anyone as Edward because we all have a very clear picture of our own "Edward" in our heads, but for the movie Robert totally and completely became him. There were definitely parts to of Midnight Sun that shown through in his performance, especially his internal struggle during the kiss scene. That was pure perfection.
Also, Kristen and Rob portrayed the love story beautifully. I always knew Kristen would make a great Bella and she nailed it.
I especially loved the scenes between her and Charlie. Speaking of Charlie, Billy Burke nailed this part as well! I just wanted to reach out and give him a big hug when Bella lied and left him. I didn't know very much about Billy as an actor going into this so his performance pleasantly surprised me.
Jacob! I love me some Jacob. I had no idea how well Taylor would do as Jacob and he's a little too young for us older fans to swoon at but I have to say that he made a fabulous Jacob! I can not wait to see New Moon because of this one actor! But also, because of the scenes in Italy, Bella jumping off the cliff, the motorcylce scenes, the wolves and that yellow porche. And if they can get an awesome cast for the Volturi, then I think New Moon will go down as the least favorite book but the most favorite movie out of the series!
The baseball scene - one scene that was okay to read in the book but ten times better to watch in the movie! This really showcased their vamp powers well. Plus, Muse was playing during the scene which made it even that much funner!
There also has never been a better intro for bad vamps in all of cinema. That was pure rock and roll.
The intensity of the ballet studio fight scene was total movie magic. Especially after Bella gets bit and Edward's siblings are tearing apart James. Kristen did an excellent job making that vampire bite seems so painful! I love how Alice almost lost control and I love the beautiful video montage that played out as Edward was trying not to kill her as he was saving her. With Rob's song "Let me Sign" playing in the background it brought me to tears.
The prom scene was my most favorite. It was so gorgeous and having been to and stayed at the place they shot it at only made it that much more special for me (click for link). That whole scene under the lighted canopy was breathtaking and it captured the enchantment of Edward and Bella's intense love for one another.
I love that scene so much I had a jeweler I recently found on Etsy named Shielou make me a necklace to depict this scene. I told her the bricks on the Inn were a dark gray and that I wanted it to look like the little Edward and Bella charms were dancing under the twinkly lights. Didn't it turn out beautiful? I couldn't be happier!
It's called "Under the Starlit Canopy"
Here is her blog: http://shielou.blogspot.com/
and her etsy store: http://www.etsy.com/shop.php?user_id=6289058
The only things I had a slight problem with in the movie were some of the special effects. I thought the sparkle effect that ILM did was fabulous, but some of the leaping and running just didn't look realistic enough. I can totally overlook these things though since the movie was so good!
It has done so well with ticket sales that this morning Summit released a statement basically saying that New Moon is a go!
The estimated sales for the opening weekend are looking like $75 million which would make this movie the biggest opening for a movie with a female director ever! Go Catherine! She is one of the coolest people in the world (she walked the whole line of 200 camped-out fans the night before the premiere taking video footage for the DVD extras and signing autographs and taking pictures with everyone) and she deserves this honor.
This is not just a movie with a female director, but a screenplay written by a female and a female leading character all because of a book by a female writer. More power to the women!
After all, Joseph Campbell stated, "Woman is the sublime acme of sensuous adventure."
Twilight is a sensuous adventure indeed.
-Britten

















