
George, Natalie(minus the hair for her role in
V for Vendetta), Hayden and Sam at the Cannes Premiere for
Episode III: Revenge of the Sith(This is from my review I posted on theforce.net message boards)
I’m going to start with my only disappointments so that I can end on a good note...
First of all, I expected a lot more kissage between Anakin and Padme. We all saw, and even had as our icons, the pic of them kissing that came out in the Insider . You know, the one where they are standing near her apartment window and she is in the black dress and he has his hand on her jaw . Anyway, HELLO!! The scene was there but no kiss!! Secondly, the number one scene I had been so excited about and been waiting for was cut as well!! For those of you who were not spoiled it went a little something like this:
Padme says to Anakin, “Do you want to feel him kick?” Anakin placing his hand on her tummy says, “What makes you so sure it’s going to be a boy?” “Motherly intuition”, Padme teases. Then Anakin says, “Well, with a kick like that, it’s got to be a girl!”
I was so looking forward to Anakin with his hand on her tummy, his future offspring, and talking about them with her!! And, for the love of the Force, we could have used another quiet, happy scene in that movie! And I just love how they are both right! I’m almost pretty sure that this scene was filmed though, because one, it was in the script, and two, you can see the very end of it at the beginning of the scene on Padme’s veranda at sunset where she has the purple and red dress on. It will most likely be a deleted scene. And I sure hope that the other kiss that was taken out is actually part of a longer scene that we will see on the DVD as well.
Another thing that I was looking forward to seeing was the young Mon Mothma, but I guess since they took out all the forming-of-the-Rebellion scenes, that she would be out too. I just didn’t put two and two together. Oh, well. I hope we get to see these scenes on the DVD too.
So it seems for the sake of pacing and time they had to cut some really good stuff out just like in AOTC. I don’t really blame them a whole lot, though, since this movie was so jam-packed with stuff!
Okay, now on the good stuff…
The opening space battle was plain awesome and I know it will be even better on a digital screen since I was able to see a portion of it on a digital screen at C3. Can’t wait for that! I loved to watch Obi-Wan and Anakin’s starfighters spin, tilt and turn exactly the same!! Just shows how much they are in tune with each other now. R2 was hilarious, of course, and I was cracking up when he was trying to hide the comlink from the super battle droids. The fight with Dooku was over quickly, but that just shows us what a strong Jedi Anakin has really become. The look on Dooku’s face was priceless, especially after reading all the novels in between AOTC and ROTS that featured him and his relationship with Palpatine and how he had a feeling he might be replaced. I loved it when Obi-Wan said “Another happy landing” when Anakin crash-landed the ship. Seemed like OT sarcasm.
That first scene with A&P was wonderful!!! The way he ran to her and then picked her up and twirled her was just ,”Awwww!” And his reaction to the pregnancy was priceless, and another part I was really looking forward to seeing. Plus, that scene was hot! The balcony scene was perfect as well and a real nod to us Defenders, I believe! You can really see how much Anakin is so madly (yes, quite!) and deeply in love with her. The end of that scene was supposed to end with them both laughing and saying that they hadn’t laughed in so long, but the way they ended it in the movie led into the dream nicely. Bare-chested Anakin is so gorgeous!! Gosh, that man is beauty defined!! Even whilst going totally evil!! I loved how he talked about giving Padme the snippet when he was young…makes her funeral scene even more poignant. And oh, so sad!!
I loved the next scene when Anakin was confiding in Yoda. Other than looking really hot with the sunlight and shadows on his face (Oh! Symbolic!) you could really feel Anakin’s anguish and frustration. I love the advice Yoda gives him, because it’s good advice for us all. Some say they didn’t like it though. To me, Anakin was just too far gone at this point to take the advice and Yoda had no real idea to whom he was referring…for all he knew, Anakin could have been talking about Obi-Wan.
I loved the goodbye scene between Obi-Wan and Anakin. Obi-Wan finally tells Anakin what he needed and wanted to hear his whole training, but like so many have already said, it came too late. I can’t blame Obi-Wan too much because as a parent it is hard to train a child to walk in righteous paths, especially one who is a little rebellious in nature. You know they need to know if they have done something wrong and parents sometimes have a tendency to be a bit too controlling at times and stingy with the praise. Sometimes we don’t know the best way to handle situations and are trying to only do what’s best for the child/young adult. Sometimes we are also afraid of giving them too much praise, which I know sounds silly, but really, sometimes you fear they will become arrogant and no longer try hard. But all the while you still love them with all your heart. I think this was the case with Obi-Wan. We all know that he loved Anakin, but I think he let his fear control his training of Anakin too much. He was afraid too much praise would go to Anakin’s head so he would constantly scold him and lecture him, which he did also because he wanted Anakin to be the best Jedi he could be. Obi-Wan just went about it all wrong with Anakin’s training much like a parent does….out of love, but mixed with fear and weakness. Let this be a lesson to us all as parents. We need to praise and outwardly love our children more than scold and lecture.
The next scenes between the Jedi and Anakin, and Palpatine and Anakin were brilliantly done. We as the audience see how, in Anakin’s eyes, the Jedi are not living up to the things they should be, i.e. putting Anakin on the Council and not making him a master, asking Anakin to spy on the Chancellor, Anakin seeing their mistrust in him, their “Chosen One”, as well as their fear controlling their actions. And then we see how Palpatine IS doing what we know Anakin wants and longs for. He strokes his ego and appoints him as his personal rep. on the council, thus furthering his career as a Jedi, he tells Anakin that the Jedi need him and that he suspects the Jedi have asked things of him they shouldn’t, further proving to Anakin that the Jedi are going against the code because of fear. The scene during the opera was very intriguing and ended up, upon second viewing, to be a much needed slow scene even though it was still intense. Palpatine is a snake! He lures Anakin in with the greatest of ease and sadly, Anakin falls for it, though if I were in his situation, so desperate and confused, I can honestly say I probably would have fallen for it all too.
Some say that Anakin’s turn is very quick and doesn’t make a whole lot of sense. One minute he’s turning Palpatine over to Mace and posse, the next he’s saving Palpatine and pledging himself to the darkside. What the? But I was TOTALLY sold on this scene. Anakin’s turn has been happening for 2 movies now, not just in this scene. When he and Padme have the Force connection across the city skyline, that seals the deal for him. Plus, when he walks in and sees Mace trying to kill Palpatine this is just one more way the Jedi are again going against the code... it’s the icing on the cake. Yet he still can’t believe he’s killed his first Jedi, which I don’t blame him for. It would be weird at first. The way he says, “What have I done?” is Oscar-worthy, IMHO! Think about when you were a kid and did something bad you knew would be an atrocity to your parents…you freak out and think, “How can I cover this up? What am I going to do now?” And for me at least, I would think, “Well, if I just become evil now I won’t feel so guilty!” Anakin knew that this was it for him. Killing Mace was not something he could live with himself for and now there was no turning back. Plus agreeing to go and kill the rest of the Jedi…well, heck! Now there will be no good side, only my side! No one to answer to? Yee-Haw! Plus I get to save Padme…a nice little deal there.
For the rest of the movie I was a basket case! I was even as spoiled as they come too! The carrying out of Order 66 was one of the saddest montages in all of film! The music there cuts your heart out! And then to top it all off with Anakin killing the younglings when it first appears to them that he is there to rescue them was, for me, the hardest thing to watch. You can even see that the youngling talking to him actually smiles at first when Anakin ignites his lightsaber probably thinking, “Oh, goody! Master Anakin is going to kick some Clone butt for us!” But then you see him suddenly realize what is about to happen and this just kills me! Anakin, you idiot! You are about to have children of your own!!! But remember, those kids, like the Tusken children are now the enemy in Anakin’s eyes and nothing more…..it’s so sad. Watching Bail watch the other youngling gunned down was horrifying as well! I’m sure this was probably what the Holocaust was like.
I just wanted to reach out and give Yoda a great big hug when he was so sad over all the deaths he felt. Seeing him that way really topped this scene off for me. He was also so cute on the gunship when he rubbed his hands in his hair and so real! Gollum real! I loved it when he climbed onto Chewbacca’s back….brought warm feelings to my heart!
I loved A&P’s last love scene together on her veranda! This was the first shot I ever saw of the two of them on the webcam and what made me venture over to TFN and start posting in the first place. Little did I know that he was actually Vader in this scene which makes it even more tender, significant and precious, IMO . Notice how Anakin is concerned for the life of his own baby, which I loved, but not that of the ones he just killed! Twisted by the darkside, indeed!
So by now I’m a mess but not to the point of shaking yet. As everyone in the movie was loosing it, so was I…..I was sobbing with Padme and crying with Anakin. The part where he is on Mustafar after he has just wiped out the Separatist leaders and he is standing on the railing looking out at the sun was so sad, and Hayden completely pulled me into Anakin’s anguish and despair here. He has just delved deeper into the darkside than ever before and it hurts! He’s just a kid and this is way too much to have to go through at such a young age, be ye Chosen One or not! You can tell he doesn’t like what he is doing, but he wants to save Padme so badly these are the lengths he will go to. This part really touched me and will be one of those deep moments of pity for Anakin for me, as I’m sure it will be for lots of people.
When Padme comes to Anakin on Mustafar we see for a brief second the Anakin we all know and love. We see him surprised but excited to see his wife. We see him holding her and looking into her eyes. But the moment she even speaks of Obi-Wan and starts accusing Anakin of terrible things that’s when we know that in the wise words of Yoda, “The boy you trained, gone he is. Consumed by Darth Vader.” Anakin is sadly, no more. Not even love can pull him back now (well, at least not until 20 years from now after all the suffering…duh!) He has totally lost it, thinking that he can overthrow Palpatine and rule the galaxy with Padme and “make things the way we want them to be”. I was right there with Padme thinking, “Who the heck is this guy?” You can see the change right before your eyes and that is why, as I knew before, the choke was understandable. When he sees Obi-Wan he snaps even further and when he screams “Liar!” at Padme I nearly wet myself! Yikes! Man, can that Hayden ever go to some dark places!! He was freaking me out! He was much more dark and scary here than Vader in the suit ever was for me as a kid.
No matter what, every time Yoda knocks those two royal guards out the audience will cheer, mostly because it comes right after one of the most intense scenes in the film and is a nice little break. I, like most of you have stated already, got goose bumps when Yoda and Palps were fighting on the rising platform in the middle of the Senate auditorium. It really makes you realize that they are fighting for the fate of the entire galaxy, as Anakin and Obi-Wan are fighting over the fate of the galaxy’s Chosen One. Great Saga moment there! I had seen them practicing the duel so many times that I noticed there were several moves that were cut, which was disappointing....like when they both punch each other one after the other, and also there was one sequence when Anakin looked as if he was trying to hurl things at Obi-Wan as they were swinging their sabers at each other or else they were both hurling things, I’m not sure. Anyway, I’m hoping I might notice these moves in the digital version which I have yet to see, but it was still amazing and I could read the fast fighting better when I watched it the second time.
When Obi-Wan admits to Anakin during the duel that he has failed him, it made me realize that even though Anakin was ultimately responsible for his choices, everyone in his life had weaknesses that affected him. Even Yoda admits that he too has failed as leader of the Jedi Order. Almost everyone in the prequels failed in some way or another. At least the two Jedi that will stick around to train Luke can admit that they failed….after all, this is the first step in the healing process.
My heart broke for Anakin/Vader (yes, even after he killed younglings and tried to kill his wife) when his remaining limbs were chopped off and he was moaning and grunting in pain and trying not to slide further down the bank of black sand. All I kept thinking was “This is that beautiful Jedi we all know and love, now in pain and agony and burning before our eyes!!” It was gut-wrenching! It shouldn’t be like this!! Beyond Shakespearean tragedy…. And then to top it all off with Obi-Wan saying he loved Anakin as Anakin says that he hates him was just, well, I felt Obi-Wan’s pain there as well. I still don’t know what to think of him leaving Anakin there to die and not trying to save him….maybe he didn’t think Anakin was going to make it anyway now with no limbs and no skin! I mean, Anakin was trying to kill him just a few seconds earlier too, so you know…I guess it can do things to a guy. I’m gunna have to think about this one further….
Vader’s mechanical hand slowly pulling his body up the bank after you think he’s got to be dead was a little "Tales from the Cript-ish" ….me likey! And just why don’t you go and tear my heart out a little bit more and have it raining on Coruscant when they bring Vader’s charred body back. It’s like the skies of the galaxy are weeping for the fall of their Chosen One! Wah! I was surprised to see that they would get as graphic as peeling off the burnt-on clothes from his body and the way he buckled in pain and threw his arm back to knock one of the droids away was so real and creepy….it was very hard to watch.
And of course, showing the supposed death of Anakin and birth of Vader while watching the death of Padme and the birth of the twins was superb film-making! Brilliant! Natalie did a very good job here in the birth scene. Some were saying that she shouldn’t be screaming like that cuz she is supposed to be having a C-section. Well, I’ve given birth naturally and was screaming and making noises I didn’t even know my body could make! It was the most painful thing ever!! And I know that one is numb during a C-section but I’ve heard from friends that you can still feel the pressure of the baby(s) being pulled out and that can freak you out, even though it’s not painful. Plus she isn’t with her husband like she thought she would be, so she is scared, and mostly because she doesn’t know what has really happened to him. I would be crying too!
And then some others can’t understand why she gave up so easily. According to Lucas, she dies of a broken heart which is a medical condition in real life. It’s called Broken Heart Syndrome and it is brought on by extreme amounts of stress and depression. You can have a heart attack from it if it gets really serious. I know Padme should be the kind of women that would find the will to live somewhere inside her for her twins, but you have to remember that this is not the same, strong leader that was introduced to us in TPM. She has changed alongside Anakin as we have all talked about before. She is more emotional now and she may have figured that her life would be filled with so much sadness now that her husband had turned to the darkside that she would not be able to be the mother her children needed.
I was a little confused why they didn’t at least have Leia open her eyes and look at her mother so that the moment she talks about her in ROTJ would make more sense, but I’m sure that she learns of her from Bail so it didn’t bother me that much. The moment that was most poignant for me and made me breakdown like a baby was the moment when Obi-Wan is still holding Luke and Padme tells him that there is still good in Anakin. No amount of spoiling could prepare me for that moment because in the book and script she hands the snippet to Obi-Wan when she says this and it never mentions Luke is still there hearing his mother say that. I was completely overcome with emotion and knew right then and there that was the reason Luke always believed in his father…because his mother did! Awe! I felt like it was my own family I was watching!! (So yeah, PLJ , you are not the only one who noticed this - I’m right there with ya! )
The ending montage made me very nostalgic for the original trilogy. I had finally seen the missing piece to the puzzle I knew was there all along! It was one of those moments I will never forget! Most everyone I have talked to absolutely loved the film and I make sure that when they tell me it was way better than the first two, I tell them that ROTS would mean NOTHING if not for those two films…this film was their climax and it wouldn’t have the impact it does on everyone without the first two to set it up. I can’t wait to have some time to watch the first two and see what might seem a little more dark and mysterious now that we know what is to come. I wasn’t crying as much the second time as I did for the first, but I can honestly say that it will take many, many more times for me to be able to get through it and not shed a tear….I may never be able to. It’s one of those films that touches you so deeply you feel you are forever changed and affected by it.
-AnakinsLuv